Can OpenAI’s Sora Stay Out of Legal Trouble? Exploring AI, Gaming, and Copyright Risks
Dec 16, 2024

Sam

Hey, did you hear about OpenAI's new AI, Sora? It makes short videos, even of video games!

Amy

Yeah, I read about it! Sora can create videos that look like famous games, but there might be some legal problems with how it was trained.

Sam

Wait, why would it have legal problems? Isn’t it just making new stuff from scratch?

Amy

Not exactly. To create those videos, Sora needs to be trained on tons of data. People think it used game walkthroughs, Twitch streams, and maybe even videos of popular streamers, like Auronplay and Pokimane.

Sam

Oh, so it copied those videos to learn? That doesn’t sound fair.

Amy

That’s the issue. Training an AI usually involves copying data to teach the model patterns. If that data is copyrighted—like video games or streams—then using it without permission might break copyright laws.

Sam

But isn’t it creating new videos? It’s not copying the original stuff exactly, right?

Amy

True, Sora’s videos aren’t direct copies. But sometimes, AI models can produce outputs that look very similar to the content they were trained on. For example, Sora made characters that look like famous streamers, even with their tattoos!

Sam

Whoa, that’s kind of creepy. So, could people sue OpenAI for that?

Amy

Possibly. Legal experts say video game content is tricky because it has layers of copyright protection. There’s the game itself, the unique video made by the player, and sometimes even user-generated content, like Fortnite custom maps.

Sam

So if Sora was trained on Fortnite playthroughs, who could sue OpenAI? The game company or the players?

Amy

Both! The game developer owns the game’s designs, the player owns their gameplay video, and if the map is custom, the map creator has rights too. That’s why this could get really messy.

Sam

Wow, I didn’t think AI could have so many legal problems. Can OpenAI argue it’s fair use?

Amy

They might try. Fair use means the AI’s training or output has to transform the original content in a big way and not hurt the market for it. But courts haven’t decided how fair use applies to AI training yet.

Sam

So, does this mean AI companies can just train models on anything they find online?

Amy

Not exactly. Some companies argue it’s like learning by watching. But others say AI training is different because it involves copying huge amounts of data. Until laws are clearer, AI companies are taking risks.

Sam

What happens if Sora makes a video that looks like a real game? Could users get in trouble too?

Amy

Yes, users might also be responsible if they publish or sell AI-generated content that’s too similar to copyrighted works. That’s why this debate is so important—for companies and for people using AI tools.

Sam

Sounds like AI and gaming have a lot to figure out. Do you think Sora’s worth the risk?

Amy

It’s exciting tech, but it’s a reminder that AI and copyright laws need to catch up. Until then, both companies and users have to be careful.